What We Know About Russia’s Use Of Twitter In 2016 Propaganda Campaign – by Sam Thielman | 11 suspected members of banned neo-Nazi terror group arrested in England and Wales | The GOP’s Stockholm Syndrome | TRUMP-RUSSIA Investigations Update: Stone may be subpoenaed | Manafort’s Offer to Russian Oligarch Was Tied to Disputed Deal

The GOP’s Stockholm Syndrome

1 Share
Like many victims, the GOP establishment failed to perceive danger before their captor bound and gagged them.



Trump’s longtime friend and adviser Roger Stone told lawmakers that he had been falsely accused of colluding with Russia during testimony to the House Intelligence Committee yesterday, when emerging from over three hours of closed-dorr questioning, Stone said that he had “correct[ed] a number of things that members of the committee had said” about him. Katie Bo Williams reports at the Hill.

Stone refused to disclose the name of his intermediary with WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, also stating after the session that he expected special counsel Robert Mueller to “manufacture” a charge against former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort in the near future. Julian Borger reports at the Guardian.

Stone may be subpoenaed, Rep. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) said yesterday, making the comments after Stone refused to respond to a key line of questioning, Reuters reports.

An analysis of Stone’s statement to the Committee is provided by Just Security Editor Renato Mariotti at Just Security.

Former national security adviser Michael Flynn and Manafort are “99 percent” likely to be indicted as part of Mueller’s investigation, Sen. Richard Blumenthal said yesterday (D-Conn.) said yesterday. Darren Samuelsohn reports at POLITICO.

“Why is the F.B.I. so focused on keeping Congress in the dark?” Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) asked yesterday, castigating the Department of Justice and the F.B.I. for not complying with requests for two F.B.I. agents to testify before the committee. Joe Uchill reports at the Hill.

The I.R.S. is providing documents to Mueller’s team about key Trump campaign officials after the agency and the team clashed during the summer – mostly due to concerns about the scope of Mueller’s investigation. Manu Raju, Pamela Brown and Evan Perez report at CNN.

“I think there was an effort to bring some chaos to the groups on the right and the left,” the Senate Intelligence Committee chairman Richard Burr (R-N.C.) said yesterday in reference to the Russian use of ads on Facebook during the presidential campaign, but stating that “there’s nothing that could learn towards one candidate versus the other.” Ali Breland reports at the Hill.

Russian-bought Facebook ads benefited Trump, Bernie Sanders and Green Party candidate Jill Stein, according to a source familiar with the ads. Josh Dawsey reports at POLITICO.

Manafort’s Offer to Russian Oligarch Was Tied to Disputed Deal – Bloomberg

1 Share

Manafort’s Offer to Russian Oligarch Was Tied to Disputed Deal
When Donald Trump’s campaign chairman offered private briefings to a Russian oligarch close to President Vladimir Putin last year, he wasn’t only appealing to a superpower, he was pursuing a personal mission: the end to a costly dispute over a failed …and more »

What We Know About Russia’s Use Of Twitter In 2016 Propaganda Campaign – TPM

1 Share

What We Know About Russia’s Use Of Twitter In 2016 Propaganda Campaign
In this case, it appears to have given useful platforms to what the U.S. intelligence community says were fronts for a Russian intelligence service. The Guccifer 2.0 and DCLeaks accounts haven’t tweeted since January 2017 and December 2016, respectively.and more »


Sam Thielman is an investigative reporter for Talking Points Memo based in Manhattan. He has worked as a reporter and critic for the Guardian, Variety, Adweek and Newsday, where he covered stories from the hacking attacks on US and international targets by Russian GRU and FSB security services to the struggle to bring broadband internet to the Navajo nation. He lives in Brooklyn with his wife and son and too many comic books.

What We Know About Russia’s Use Of Twitter In 2016 Propaganda Campaign – Talking Points Memo

1 Share

Subscribe to TPM Prime for a better reading experience, exclusive features and to support our reporters’ award-winning journalism.

In recent weeks, Facebook has received the lion’s share of attention when it comes to the social media component of Russia’s interference in the U.S. election. But the service the President so frequently and famously uses hasn’t received quite the same level of scrutiny yet—perhaps because it’s much harder to nail down exactly what happened on Twitter during the 2016 campaign.

Much of the activity on Twitter is a morass of bot traffic, spam accounts mobbing hashtags and plain old harassment, so teasing out the Twitter component of a coordinated influence campaign that spanned multiple platforms is a seriously tall order. Sens. Mark Warner (D-VA) and Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) have proposed some of the first regulations that would specifically affect Twitter and Facebook; a Twitter spokesman told TPM that, regarding regulation, “we are open to discussing this with the FEC and Congress.”

There are a few facts about Russian-linked activity on Twitter during the 2016 campaign we already know thanks to published reports, but there’s much more that remains unclear. Answers to some of those unanswered questions could emerge from Twitter’s closed-door meeting with the Senate Intelligence Committee on Wednesday.

Guccifer 2.0 and DCLeaks spread propaganda on Twitter

The primary arms of the Russian disinformation campaign operated on Twitter—in fact, you still can visit the Twitter pages for DCLeaks and Guccifer 2.0, two of the outlets for emails stolen from Democratic organizations and operatives.

Twitter has a laissez-faire attitude toward who can and can’t use its network; short of distributing something illegal or advocating violence—and sometimes even then—users can do pretty much whatever they want with impunity. In this case, it appears to have given useful platforms to what the U.S. intelligence community says were fronts for a Russian intelligence service.

The Guccifer 2.0 and DCLeaks accounts haven’t tweeted since January 2017 and December 2016, respectively.

Groups of synchronized, automated accounts promoted Trump in the interest of Russians

Russian intelligence also used networks of automated accounts, or social botnets, on Twitter, although it’s hard to tell which were actually harnessed by the GRU and which were simply a function of Russia’s burgeoning cybercrime industry. Much of the work that has been done tracking bot accounts is inductive, which has made the task of labeling bot accounts a perilous one. Plenty of amateur Trump-Russia sleuths have managed to look foolish for accusing run-of-the-mill conservative Twitter users of being Russian bots.

But some of the reasoning is convincing and comes from reliable sources. Cybersecurity researcher Brian Krebs, formerly a reporter for the Washington Post, noted that any time he criticized Putin, it mysteriously generated defensive tweets about Trump. He also observed that the service’s like and retweet buttons were being used as part of a strategic offense.

Russian-linked accounts promoted fake news stories

Russian social botnets appear to have been used to promote a lot of far-right news hashtags, according to Hamilton 68, a program that tracks probable bots of Russian origin. This is in itself not especially unusual. Twitter charges to promote tweets and tags on its service, so an underhanded advertiser may feel the need to promote its work through a network of linked accounts that will get it the requisite number of likes and retweets.

But a January report from the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (DNI) in noted that Russian state-affiliated bloggers had prepared such a campaign for Clinton’s victory. “Before he election, Russian diplomats had publicly denounced the US electoral process and were prepared to publicly call into question the validity of the results,” the report’s authors wrote. “Pro- Kremlin bloggers had prepared a Twitter campaign, #DemocracyRIP, on election night in anticipation of Secretary Clinton’s victory, judging from their social media activity.”

At other moments, Russian Twitter users glommed onto the far-right news of the day, including the conspiracy theory that murdered Democratic National Committee staffer Seth Rich had something to do with the stolen emails.

Russians ran at least one pro-Trump news account

The @tpartynews account had some 22,000 followers and regularly insulted Black Lives Matter activists. The account was followed by former Trump advisor Sebastian Gorka, who himself has been linked to far-right racist and anti-Semitic groups in Hungary.

How much bot traffic was actually directed by Russian intelligence?

Bot traffic on Twitter is vast. While it accounted for 33 percent of pro-Trump tweets during the run-up to the 2016 election, it also accounted for 22 percent of pro-Clinton tweets. It’s very difficult to tell which tweets are of Russian origin and which Russian tweets are part of a Kremlin influence campaign. Much of this simply speaks to a vulnerability on the platform that activists have been complaining about for years: Twitter’s sign-up process is very simple and open to abuse by anyone who, for whatever reason, wants to promote a malicious agenda or harass other users.

To what extent did Russia use Twitter’s ad technology?

We now know Russian operators used Facebook to run ad campaigns around divisive social issues. They made use of the company’s microtargeting capabilities, which are especially effective at locating people who may be sympathetic to the deluge of anti-Clinton, pro-Trump news that the GRU had already seeded through WikiLeaks, Guccifer 2.0 and DCLeaks. Twitter hasn’t yet answered the question of whether Russian intelligence was able to operate to its satisfaction merely using botnets and sock-puppet accounts like @tpartynews, or whether it needed to buy promoted tweets or hashtags; so far there’s no evidence that it did.

Why are some Russian accounts dormant while others are still active?

One group tracking Russian bots notes that many of them haven’t stopped tweeting. In fact, they tweeted in support of alt-right groups in the aftermath of the slaying of Heather Heyer at a white supremacist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia. Again, some of this is inductive reasoning: ProPublica identified one account as a bot by noting it used a stolen photo, sent five tweets in a single minute that all used a URL shortener, and that the account’s tweets “were reported to use similar language from Russian government–backed outlets Sputnik and RT.” Of course, all this could be true of a human account, too.

What does Twitter plan to do about any of this?

Twitter is due on Capitol Hill Wednesday and Thursday. The company has thus far been tight-lipped about its strategy for dealing with malicious foreign governments trying to tamper in each others’ elections—similar influence campaigns in France and Germany have taken place since the American election. The company may come up with some kind of internal proposal for enhancing its ability to detect and root out activity like the GRU influence campaign in much the same way it, along with Facebook, has agreed to help the U.S. deal with social media accounts run by the Islamic State.

Government contractor arrested by counter-terror police over Official Secrets Act – The Independent

1 Share

The Independent
Government contractor arrested by counter-terror police over Official Secrets Act
The Independent
… was arrested at an address in north London by officers “acting upon intelligence received.” She was arrested on suspicion of an offence contrary to section 1 of the Official Secret Act 1911, and was detained under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act.and more »

National Action: 11 suspected members of banned neo-Nazi terror group arrested in England and Wales – The Independent

1 Share

The Independent
National Action: 11 suspected members of banned neo-Nazi terror group arrested in England and Wales
The Independent
Police have arrested 11 suspected members of a neo-Nazi group on suspicion of terror offences across England and Wales. Six men were arrested in north west England, including one suspect who was already in prison, two in Wales, two in West Yorkshire …
UK counter-terror police arrest 11 amid far-right probeHouston Chronicle
Anti-terror police arrest 11 men in national sting on neo-Nazi terror groupManchester Evening Newsall 24 news articles »


  • 1K